NFL Draft: 1st Round recap and Grades.
This fall, the Auburn fans voted DJ Khaled’s “All I do is Win” in as the tunnel music for the football team’s field entrance. Despite the awfulness of the song, it caught on, and became a sensation. Some would even give this song a piece of the credit for the Tiger’s sensational undefeated season. Either way, the fact that ESPN chose this as the intro song for the 2011 NFL draft is all to perfect. In moments- nay, as I’m typing - Cameron Newton will become the #1 overall selection in the NFL draft. War Eagle! Let’s get to it:
#1 Carolina Panthers (B+): Cameron Newton, QB/ Auburn. Well, it’s official! Mr. Newton is headed to Carolina. He has never had any trouble rising above the naysayers and haters before, and there will be plenty more after this selection. It’s been a hell of a year for Cam, achieving pretty much everything a college football player can possibly accomplish. Now it’s time for him to put his nose to the grindstone and prove he can become a viable starting Quarterback in the NFL.
#2 Denver Broncos (C-): Von Miller, OLB/ Texas A&M. Von Miller is a great prospect and a phenomenal athlete. There is no doubting that. There is, however, reason to doubt his effectiveness in Denver’s 4-3 Defense. He seems to be in the mold of a player like Brian Orakpo. That is, a terror rushing off the edge of a 3-4 Defense. Great player, maybe not a great pick for Denver, especially at #2 overall.
#3 Buffalo Bills (B): Marcel Dareus, DT/ Alabama. I will not argue that Marcel Dareus is a great football player. And he’s been highly touted for a long time. And I have very little doubt Marcel will quickly develop into a dependable interior lineman in the NFL. I do, however, question his value this high in the draft. While he is a very good football player, I just don’t see him as the explosive player many envision him as.
#4 Cincinnati Bengals (A+): AJ Green, WR/ Georgia. Well, Damn! I was really holding out hope Green would fall to the Browns at #6. Green is probably the best receiver I have ever seen play, with incredible hands and absolutely uncanny body control. I have little to no doubt the Bengals have drafted their #1 Wideout for a long, long time.
#5 Arizona Cardinals (A-): Patrick Peterson, CB/ LSU. Great pick here. Peterson could pretty easily be considered the best athlete in the draft. He’s got insane raw ability, and isn’t exactly raw in his coverage skills. He’s also not afraid to deliver a blow. The Cardinals have themselves a keeper in Peterson.
#6 Atlanta Falcons via Cleveland (C): Julio Jones, WR/ Alabama. Huge package to give up for Jones, I love the trade for Cleveland. For Atlanta, while the price may have been steep, they picked up a good player. Jones is a dependable worker bee, who will not shy away from contact. He isn’t the explosive athlete you’d picture in a WR taken this high, and he doesn’t have the greatest hands, but he makes up for it in size and toughness. Playing opposite of Roddy White should benefit him greatly.
#7 San Francisco 49ers (C): Aldon Smith, DE/ Missouri. Who would have thought Smith would be the first Missouri Tiger off the board? I think this might be a bit of a reach for Smith, considering the other Defensive Ends available in this draft. But Smith has a solid track record, and while a bit of an injury risk, he is less of a risk than other blue chip ends like De’Quan Bowers. And with Isaac Sopoaga slated to start for the 49ers at DE, Aldon will have a chance to contribute immediately.
#8 Tennessee Titans (D-): Jake Locker, QB/ Washington. I’ve seen Jake Locker play Quarterback. Usually late at night on Fox Sports, but I’ve seen it happen. In my eyes, this guy simply is not a good QB. I don’t understand the hype, or what the scouts see in him. Sure, he’s tough as nails and he may be a strong leader, but it takes a lot more than that to win in the league. I’ll personally be shocked if he becomes an average starter at any point. Maybe most of the problem was that he was playing at Washington. That’s what I’d be hoping if I was a Titans fan.
#9 Dallas Cowboys (B-): Tyron Smith, OT/ Southern Cal. I don’t trust this guy. Not sure why he was playing RT instead of LT at USC. Also not sure why he never seemed to develop or improve while a Trojan. That being said, he is built in the perfect mold of a professional left tackle. If Dallas can polish him up, they’ll have a great pick here. But still, something about him just doesn’t add up.
#10 Jacksonville Jaguars via Washington (C-): Blaine Gabbert, QB/ Missouri. Oh, Blaine Gabbert. I don’t think this kid belongs anywhere near the 1st round. I just don’t understand the hype, or what anyone sees in him. He’s not a leader. He’s not tough. He can’t throw downfield. He struggles on 3rd down. He’s not a particularly good athlete. If Gabbert ever leads an NFL team into the playoffs, I will be stunned.
#11 Houston Texans (B): JJ Watt, DE/ Wisconsin. Can the former Scout Teamer become an impact player in the NFL? I have my doubts. However, this kid might have the best work ethic in the entire draft, and it’s pretty amazing how far he’s come in the past few years. If he can adjust to, and handle, NFL competition, this could be an excellent pick.
#12 Minnesota Vikings (F): Christian Ponder, QB/ Florida State. I thought this selection was a joke. Locker at #8 was bad enough. Christian Ponder at #12 overall? Pure lunacy. How many QB competitions did this kid have to win at FSU? Didn’t he lose the job to some kid named Xavier Lee once? Or was that still Drew Weatherford? Does it make a difference, really? Look, Ponder may not be hopeless, but the Vikings are certainly betting against the odds here.
#13 Detroit Lions (A): Nick Fairley, DT/ Auburn. I understand the concerns with Nick. He was a JUCO who enrolled at Auburn without a position. He played sporadically for a year before bursting onto the scene and becoming one of the most dominant interior lineman in recent SEC history.
#14 St. Louis Rams (D): Robert Quinn, DE/ North Carolina. I give this pick a ‘D’ on principle alone. The Rams have drafted enough D-linemen over the past few years to know they shouldn’t be drafting defensive linemen. I firmly believe the organization should have done everything within their power to acquire a weapon for Bradford as early as possible. To compound the problem, Quinn missed an entire year of football due to suspension, and has a potentially hindering brain tumor. Quinn has extreme talent, but I don’t think it justifies this pick. I just don’t like it.
#15 Miami Dolphins (B+): Mike Pouncey, C/ Florida. Pouncey may have gotten off to a terrible start in his final season in the Swamp, but he came around in the long run, becoming one of the best linemen in the conference, as many expected he would be. If he can come close to duplicating his brother’s success as a rookie, this will be an excellent pick for the Dolphins.
#16 Washington Redskins via Jaguars (B+): Ryan Kerrigan, DE/ Purdue. I love Kerrigan, and think he will be a terror lined up opposite Orakpo. The Redskins really have no excuse no to be blitzing on every play next season. However, I don’t think picking up another elite edge rusher should have been their top priority. That’s the only thing keeping this pick from being an ‘A’.
#17 New England Patriots via Raiders (A): Nate Solder, OT/ Colorado. The only knock on Nate is his lack of polish. With that in mind, look at what the Patriots have managed to do essentially coaching up linemen off of the street over the past few years. Solder is the perfect lineman for the Patriots. I have no doubt the Pats will quickly develop him into one of the premier Tackles in the league.
#18 San Diego Chargers (B): Corey Liuget, DT/ Illinois. Good, safe pick. Liuget has all the tools to step in and be an immediate contributor at any spot along the Chargers line. Expect to see him on the field early and often, with the potential for early production.
#19 New York Giants (A): Prince Amukamara, CB/ Nebraska. There just seems to be something about Prince that instills confidence. For me, I believe it’s the silky smooth manner in which he plays his position. His only knock is his inability to deliver a big blow, but there are plenty of premier corners in the NFL who aren’t laying any lumber. I really think the Giants got a great one here.
#20 Tampa Bay Buccaneers (B-): Adrian Clayborn, DT/ Iowa. I really like Adrian Clayborn, but I’m not convinced he possesses the all-around talent to justify his status as a first rounder. Tampa Bay, however, is in need of a sack specialist, and if there is one thing Clayborn is good at, it is punishing quarterbacks. Solid pick that fills a positional need.
#21 Cleveland Browns via Chiefs (C-): Phil Taylor, DT/ Baylor. I had never even heard of Taylor before this pick, which break my heart. Of course my Browns draft the first player I know literally nothing about. I’ve come to learn he’s a run stopping nose tackle. So, essentially, he’s replacing Shaun Rogers. I can only hope he can stay on the field in Cleveland more than Shaun ever did.
#22 Indianapolis Colts (A): Anthony Castonzo, OT/ Boston College. This is another one of those picks that just feels right. Perhaps there’s a reason why teams like the Colts and Patriots are consistently excellent in a league lauded for its parity.
#23 Philadelphia Eagles (C): Danny Watkins, OT/ Baylor. Another big kid from Baylor I’ve never heard of. Guess I should have tried to catch some more Bears football this past season. Either way, this is a developmental pick, and I won’t say much more than, meh.
#24 New Orleans Saints (A): Cameron Jordan DE/ Cal. Excellent value here, but why wouldn’t they draft Mark Ingram. The Saints need a running back in the worst way, and Ingram is the best in the draft. With that said, Jordan is a beast. He probably won’t rack up tons of sacks or huge numbers, but he will definitely make a difference along the Saints front seven. Many pundits had Jordan projected as a top 15 pick.
#25 Seattle Seahawks (D): James Carpenter OG/ Alabama. Way too early for a somewhat uninspiring utility lineman from Alabama. My bias against the Tide really doesn’t change the fact that this pick is pretty stupid with Derek Sherrod’s name still on the board. Especially if a versatile backup is the position being filled. Strange.
#26 Kansas City Chiefs (B+): Jon Baldwin WR/ Pittsburgh. Baldwin’s name would probably be much more recognizable if he wasn’t being thrown to by Pitt QBs for his entire college career. If Baldwin settles in with the Chiefs, he could easily develop into an extremely dangerous downfield threat to compliment Dwayne Bowe. Very raw, but this kid’s potential is through the roof.
#27 Baltimore Ravens (A+): Jimmy Smith CB/ Colorado. While clearly a grade A talent, the kid is clearly a thug. The Raven’s Defense is also a collection of hoodlums and thugs. He will fit in perfectly. I wonder if they drink 40’s and Hennessy out of paper bags at half-time? Is Vontez Burfict available in this draft? Someday that kid will replace Ray Lewis.
#28 New Orleans Saints (B+): Mark Ingram RB/ Alabama. This bumps the Saints previous selection up to an ‘A’. Excellent value all around. Ingram may have injury concerns, but I don’t think they’re serious enough to completely discount a former Heisman winning running back. I can easily see Ingram becoming a tough, grind it out, 25 carry per game back. If he’s supported by Reggie Bush in New Orleans, they could have a very dangerous backfield.
#29 Chicago Bears (A): Gabe Carimi OT/ Wisconsin. This guy seems like he was born to be an offensive lineman for Wisconsin, and now the Chicago Bears. Gabe should feel right at home from day one on a perpetually gritty, road grading Bear’s offensive line.
#30 New York Jets (D): Muhammad Wilkerson DT/ Temple. Only the Jets would have the nerve to draft a kid from Temple in the first round of the NFL draft in front of those nutty fans always in attendance. Kiper seems to like him, but who cares? Going from Temple to the NFL must be like going from
#31 Pittsburgh Steelers (A): Cameron Heyward DE/ Ohio State. He’s got a great pedigree, he’s got a great motor, and he’s a monster. How do the Steelers always manage to end up with players like this at the tail end of the first round? I’d be shocked if this kid doesn’t step up and produce for the Steelers in the near future.
#32 Green Bay Packers (C+): Derek Sherrod OT/ Mississippi State. I never once envisioned Sherrod as a first round draft pick. He’s a very nice, very useful offensive lineman. But he doesn’t possess the upside most teams look for in their first selection. The good thing for the Packers is Derek is very versatile, and should be able to slide along the line wherever they should need to plug him in. So, overall, a decent pick with little upside for the defending champs.